Text vs Phone Reminders: What the Research Says About Dental No-Shows
What Cochrane, a dental trial, and an orthodontic meta-analysis say about text and phone reminders, and a simple way to test your own practice.
Quick Answer
Reminders work, and text reminders work about as well as phone calls in general healthcare. A Cochrane review of eight randomized trials found that text reminders raised attendance compared with no reminders, and performed about the same as phone call reminders at a lower cost. The dental evidence is thinner and mixed: an orthodontic meta-analysis found that reminders lowered the risk of failed or cancelled appointments, one randomized trial at a university pediatric dental clinic found that voice reminders beat text, and a study of patient-chosen reminders in a private orthodontic practice found no significant difference between text, email, and phone. The practical answer is to send a reminder, ask each patient how they want to hear from you, and measure your own results.
Key Takeaways
- Some reminder beats none. Across the trials in a Cochrane review, attendance was 67.8% with no reminder and 78.6% with a text reminder.
- In general healthcare, text and phone call reminders performed about the same on attendance, and text cost less per attended appointment.
- Dental evidence is thinner and mixed. An orthodontic meta-analysis found that reminders lowered the risk of failed or cancelled appointments, but one dental randomized trial found voice reminders beat text, and a study of patient-chosen reminders found no significant difference between channels.
- The studies are older and come from specific settings, mostly orthodontic and university clinics, so no study can tell you what will work in your office.
- Ask patients how they want to be reminded, and record it. The dental trial assigned the channel, and its authors suggested testing patient-chosen reminders. In one orthodontic practice where patients chose, no-show rates did not differ significantly by channel.
- Measure your own no-show rate before and after you change anything. A four-week test gives a first read.
By the numbers (Cochrane review of trials, 2013):
- 67.8% attendance with no reminder.
- 78.6% attendance with a text message reminder.
- 80.3% attendance with a phone call reminder.
A missed appointment is an empty chair and a gap in the day that cannot easily be refilled. The Cochrane reviewers note that patients' forgetfulness is one of the main reasons for missed appointments, which is why reminders are a common first step. The more useful question is which kind of reminder works, and for whom.
Claims about large drops in no-shows are not the same as controlled research. This guide sticks to published studies, and says plainly where the evidence is limited.
What the Research Found
Text reminders in general healthcare: a Cochrane review
The Cochrane review (Gurol-Urganci and colleagues, 2013) pooled eight randomized controlled trials with 6,615 participants. Its main findings:
- Text reminders improved attendance compared with no reminders (risk ratio 1.14, 95% confidence interval 1.03 to 1.26, seven studies).
- Text reminders had a similar effect to phone call reminders (risk ratio 0.99, 95% confidence interval 0.95 to 1.02, three studies).
- Two studies reported that the cost per attended appointment was 55% and 65% lower for text than for phone call reminders.
The authors rated the evidence as low to moderate quality, and their searches ran to August 2012. They concluded the evidence was still insufficient to inform policy decisions conclusively. The review covers healthcare appointments in general, not dentistry specifically.
Reminders in orthodontics: a systematic review and meta-analysis
A 2019 review in the European Journal of Orthodontics (Mohammed and colleagues) included 14 randomized trials with 2,078 participants in total, and judged the evidence that reminders improve oral hygiene and appointment adherence to be of moderate-to-high quality. Pooled results from four of the trials showed that the risk of failing or cancelling an appointment was lower in the reminder group (risk ratio 0.39, 95% confidence interval 0.22 to 0.70). The review covers reminder systems in general, not text messages specifically, and its search ran to January 2018. Its patients were orthodontic patients.
Text versus voice in a pediatric dental clinic: a randomized trial
A trial published in the Journal of the American Dental Association (Nelson and colleagues, 2011) invited 543 caregiver and child pairs from the pediatric dentistry clinic at the University of Washington. The researchers randomly assigned 318 pairs to receive either a text message (158 pairs) or a voice message (160 pairs) as the appointment reminder. The no-show rate was 17.7% in the text group and 8.2% in the voice group. The authors concluded that text messaging may not be the preferable reminder method in a university pediatric dental clinic, and suggested future studies of patients who choose their own reminder type and of settings outside universities.
Patient-chosen reminders in a private orthodontic practice
A retrospective study in the Angle Orthodontist (Wegrzyniak and colleagues, 2018) looked at 1,193 appointments for 261 patients over six months in 2015 at one office of a private orthodontic practice. Patients had chosen their own reminder method. The no-show rate was 3.49% for phone call reminders, 2.68% for email, and 1.90% for text, and the differences were not statistically significant (P = .569). The authors suggested that providers may want to let patients choose their reminder method. They also noted that their email and text reminders did not let patients confirm the appointment, and that a confirmation option might have lowered no-shows further. Their study was retrospective, covered one office, and did not test a confirmation option.
| Study | Setting | What it found | What to keep in mind |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cochrane review, 2013 | General healthcare, 8 randomized trials | Text beat no reminder; text matched phone calls; text cost less per attended visit | Not dental. Low to moderate quality. Trials ran to 2012 |
| Orthodontic meta-analysis, 2019 | Orthodontic patients, 14 randomized trials | Reminders lowered the risk of failed or cancelled appointments | Orthodontics only. Reminder types not specific to text. Search ran to 2018 |
| JADA trial, 2011 | University pediatric dental clinic, 318 randomized pairs | Voice reminders had fewer no-shows than text (8.2% vs 17.7%) | One clinic type. Channel was assigned, not chosen. Published in 2011 |
| Patient-chosen study, 2018 | Private orthodontic practice, 1,193 appointments | No significant difference between phone (3.49%), email (2.68%), and text (1.90%) | Retrospective. One office. No confirmation option tested |
Summaries of published studies. None tests a general dental practice with today's patients, which is why measuring your own results matters.
What This Means for a Practice
1. Send Something to Every Patient
Both reviews above found that reminders beat no reminder. If any patients in your schedule get no reminder at all, that is the first gap to close.
2. Ask Patients How They Want to Hear From You
The dental trial assigned the reminder channel, and its authors suggested studying patients who choose for themselves. In the study where patients did choose, no-show rates did not differ significantly between text, email, and phone. Asking at booking or check-in, and recording the answer in the chart, costs almost nothing. Follow the messaging and consent rules that apply to your practice.
3. Ask for a Response
A reminder that asks the patient to confirm gives your team an earlier signal. A patient who replies that they cannot come two days ahead leaves time to offer the slot to someone else. A patient who says nothing is the one to follow up with. The authors of the patient-chosen study noted that a confirmation option might have lowered their no-show rate further, although they did not test it.
4. Have a Plan for the Open Slot
A cancellation is only useful if you can fill it. Keep a short-notice list of patients who want an earlier visit. See how to prepare your schedule for a busy period for one way to build it.
5. Measure What Changes
A new reminder method should earn its place. Track no-shows before and after, as the next two sections show.
How to Measure Your Own No-Show Rate
Definitions vary, so start with a simple one and keep it consistent:
- No-show rate = appointments where the patient did not arrive and did not cancel, divided by appointments scheduled, for the same period.
- Late cancellation rate = appointments cancelled too late to refill, divided by appointments scheduled. Decide what "too late" means in your office, such as under 24 hours.
- Count them separately. Both leave an empty chair, but they may need different fixes.
- Break results out by reminder channel where your system allows it, and by appointment type, since different visit types may behave differently.
A Simple 4-Week Test
To find out what works for your patients, change one thing at a time and compare against your own baseline:
- Week 0: record your current no-show and late cancellation rates for the last 4 to 8 weeks.
- Week 1: keep everything the same and record the rate, so you know your normal week-to-week variation.
- Weeks 2 to 4: change one thing, such as adding a text reminder, or letting patients choose their channel.
- After week 4: compare the rate with your baseline. A small practice has few appointments, so avoid reading too much into a difference of one or two visits.
- Then: keep what helps, and repeat the test for the next change.
Where Marea Fits
Marea Comms is an AI receptionist that answers calls and texts and books patients into your schedule. A patient can text the practice's number to get questions answered and book an appointment, the same things the voice receptionist does by phone. Here is how that connects to this guide:
- Patients can reach the practice by phone or by text and book either way, which gives them more than one way to get to your schedule.
- Marea Comms is not a reminder tool, so use the steps and the test above with whichever reminder method your practice already uses.
- Your team still decides how to follow up with patients who do not respond, and what to do with the open slot.
What it does not do: Marea Comms does not replace your reminder process or the measurement above. See Marea's plans page for current plans.
Related read: The 7pm Call Problem Nobody Talks About.
See Marea Comms book an appointment. Book a 15-minute demo to see Marea Comms answer a call or a text and book the visit into your schedule. Book a demo.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do text message reminders reduce dental no-shows?
In general healthcare, a Cochrane review of randomized trials found that text reminders improved attendance compared with no reminders. In dentistry, the evidence is thinner and mixed. An orthodontic meta-analysis found that reminders lowered the risk of failed or cancelled appointments, while one randomized trial at a university pediatric dental clinic found that voice reminders outperformed text.
Are text reminders better than phone calls?
Not necessarily. The Cochrane review found text reminders had a similar effect on attendance to phone call reminders, and cost less per attended appointment. The dental trial found fewer no-shows with voice than with text, while a study of patient-chosen reminders in an orthodontic practice found no significant difference between phone, email, and text. A sensible approach is to ask patients how they want to be reminded and measure the results in your own practice.
How do I calculate my dental practice's no-show rate?
Divide the number of appointments where the patient did not arrive and did not cancel by the number of appointments scheduled for the same period. Track late cancellations separately, because they may need different fixes.
Should patients choose how they get reminders?
It is a sensible approach. The dental trial assigned the reminder channel, and its authors suggested studying patients who choose their own. In an orthodontic practice where patients chose, no-show rates did not differ significantly by channel. Asking at booking or check-in and recording the answer costs very little. Follow the messaging and consent rules that apply to your practice.
How long should I test a new reminder method?
Four weeks is a reasonable start, compared against your own baseline from the previous 4 to 8 weeks. Small practices have few appointments, so avoid reading too much into a difference of one or two visits.
Can patients book an appointment by text with Marea?
Yes. A patient can text the practice's number to get questions answered and book an appointment, the same things Marea Comms does by phone. Marea Comms is not a reminder tool, so reminders still come from the practice's own reminder method.
Sources & Further Reading
Marea resources
External sources
- Cochrane: Mobile phone messaging reminders for attendance at healthcare appointments (Gurol-Urganci et al., 2013)
- Evidence-Based Dentistry: Among orthodontic patients, does the use of reminder systems improve appointment adherence? (commentary on Mohammed et al., 2019)
- Dental Elf: Text messaging to reduce failed appointments (summary of Nelson et al., J Am Dent Assoc, 2011)
- Dental Elf: Orthodontic reminders improved compliance (summary of Mohammed et al., Eur J Orthod, 2019)
- Angle Orthodontist: Measuring the effectiveness of patient-chosen reminder methods in a private orthodontic practice (Wegrzyniak et al., 2018)
More from the Marea blog
Marea is the patient satisfaction platform for dental practices: one system that answers the call, writes the note while you treat, and sends the referral that follows, on the PMS you already use.